A forgotten melody pulls Sarah, a queer woman in New York, into the lives of the women who came before her: Cait, her 17th-century Scottish ancestor, and Jean, a spirited Irish teenager a century later. Across three centuries, they face the same defining question: what does it mean to become a mother — and at what cost? Tania Azevedo’s direction is, quite frankly, a masterclass in how to stage a musical properly. It’s clear, concise, and, crucially, never contradictory. Which